Jump to content

Linux DHCP and Windows XP problem


Guest wt_morse
 Share

Recommended Posts

Guest wt_morse

Dear Sir,

I have a peculiar problem that quite

frankly has me stumped. I am running Mandrake

9.0 on my company server which is also acting as

our DHCP server and our internet gateway. We

have a dozen or so machines running everything

from Windows 95 to XP. All of the windows 95

through Windows ME machine work fine. Here is

the interesting part. The main hub is up-linked

to to another hub in an adjoining office. On

that hub there is an XP machine and a old 95

machine. The XP machine has a shared network

drive on the 95 machine. Since I have connected

the new Linux DHCP server whenever the XP

machine machine reboots the XP GUI claims the

network drive mounted on the 95 machine is disconnected. Buut, clicking on

the icon connects the drive right away? If I use

a Lynksys DSL router as our dhcp server the

problem goes away and the XP GUI is correct. I

have shut down every service on the server

except for the DHCP server and I still get the

same results. What can the Linksys router be

doing that my fancy server is not? I am stumped

on this one. I do know that XP is an offshoot of

NT and everything from 95 to ME is Windows.

Somewhere in that difference might explain why

the other older machine still work flawlessly.

Unfortunately my knowledge of NT is limited. If

you have any thoughts or insight to this problem

it would be hugely appreciated. Thank you in

advance!

Bill Morse

Opera Systems Inc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't exaclty know - but I used to have XP on my laptop and I found the networking to be rubbish. It could ony l see my Linux desktop if I restarted samba and then, only by it's IP address.

 

When I went back to 2000 (also based on NT) there were no problems.

 

It could just be that networking on XP is broken - and that's not an anti MS rant, just my experience

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't exaclty know - but I used to have XP on my laptop and I found the networking to be rubbish.  It could ony l see my Linux desktop if I restarted samba and then, only by it's IP address.

 

When I went back to 2000 (also based on NT) there were no problems.

 

It could just be that networking on XP is broken - and that's not an anti MS rant, just my experience

 

It's not just that, XP does not get along well with win95 98 Me in my experience. Especially XP home if you ever have the misfortune of using it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I am not wrong, the name XP Home is misleading because it is not a member of the winNT/2000/XP-pro lineage. WinXP home is based on the win95/98/ME lineage with some stuff stolen from the winNT/2000/XP-pro software base. Its possible that in the process it has lost some good features of both.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I am not wrong, the name XP Home is misleading because it is not a member of the winNT/2000/XP-pro lineage. WinXP home is based on the win95/98/ME lineage with some stuff stolen from the winNT/2000/XP-pro software base. Its possible that in the process it has lost some good features of both.

 

I was under the impression that XP home is the same as XP pro except it has been neutered so as to make it non usuable for business, therefore allowing m$ to charge more for pro.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My advice: Stick with win2k (atleast SP1 or SP2, not SP3). To date that is the most stable MS OS, desktop or server. If u have to use MS$ windoze, please don't waste money on any of win95/98/98SE/ME/XP-home.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually 98SE can be categorized as a good enough OS if your primary use is gaming. It seems have the best balance of DOS gaming compatibility and Windows gaming compatibility among all the 9x based OS. Too bad it's going to be EOLed soon.

 

 

But I agree.. Win2k Pro SP1 and SP2 is the best OS M$ has made.. Everybody thinks that they are going downhill with XP, even some MS Zealots I know.

 

I never realized that XP home actually used 9X core.. sheesh.. M$ a liar.. that's news to me.. not..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...