IMHO is better to build into the kernel only the things that you know you'll always need and have the rest compiled as modules. That will create a little kernel and thus a faster one. Also if you have a slow machine like mine, the best choice is to not compile at all any superflous features -- even as a modules (a kernel compilation in a 166MHz is a pain)
But, what do you want me to say, If I'd had a machine like yours I'd compile the kernel w/o looking at the config file. I'd use all the features available -- just a joke, the fun comes tweaking the config file ;)