Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Microsoft Knowledge Base Article - 314458
MandrivaUsers.org > News, Discussion and Chat > Everything Linux
iphitus
A friend thought it would be a good idea to show me this

http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?...kb;en-us;314458

I think not!! LOL

And these lines caught my attention:

""Disk partitioning software may cause instability with the Windows XP installation. ""

LOL. I bet they put things in to stop people from doing this and installing Linux.


""Microsoft does not support the installation of Windows XP on partitions manipulated in this manner. ""

SO we can't get support for the unstable, support requiring, Windex OS if we have Linux.

James
SteamCat
hehe, MS stating in so many words that Windows is not acutally an operating system. Just a program that simulates some OS functions. laugh.gif
Gowator
Supporting windows is hard enough for them without people using third party disk partitioning software.

Being serious, quite a few of us have screwed an mbr...in linux.
anon
QUOTE
hehe, MS stating in so many words that Windows is not acutally an operating system. Just a program that simulates some OS functions. laugh.gif

laugh.gif laugh.gif laugh.gif
aRTee
Sorry, I disagree.

The full paragraph states:
QUOTE
Note that there are other ways to remove the Linux operating system and install Windows XP. The preceding method is included in this article because of the assumptions that the Linux operating system is already functioning and there is no more room on the hard disk. There are methods for changing partition sizes with software designed for managing partitions. Disk partitioning software may cause instability with the Windows XP installation. Microsoft does not support the installation of Windows XP on partitions manipulated in this manner.


Which to me means that when resizing partitions for WinXP, this may lead to problems for WinXP and they can't support that. Normally, the partition program should support any such problem (partition magic or whatever).
Note that if partitions don't start and end on the exact boundary, and thus are badly defined (which happens, it happened to me with partition magic), this may give problems, depending on the file system.
It may well be that NTFS is such a picky filesystem.

So to me this is not fud from ms against linux, it's just being clear about creating a crappy system. Honesty about being second best wrapped in hard to understand words.
No linux fud.
Just plain old MS software -- instable and problematic due to the user, not the system itself (yeah, right) -- and no warranty...

Then again, who would ever need any info on that page?
Rare are the stories of those who moved to linux and moved back to windows.
phunni
They do make the following point:
QUOTE
NOTE: Windows XP and Linux can coexist on the same computer. For additional information, refer to your Linux documentation.


Which is fair enough. It's also quite reasonable that MS wouldn't want you to do this, but its good that they point out that you can
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.